Advertisement
Smoking and vaping
Opinion
SCMP Editorial

Editorial | Hong Kong’s new anti-smoking rules need to be implemented with care

Enforcement of a multipronged tobacco control regime will be a challenge. The government should seriously consider lawmakers’ suggestions

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
1
A man vapes in the street in Hang Hau. Even as Hong Kong tightens tobacco controls, a schools organisation has called for tougher measures, including banning vaping devices. Photo: Elson LI
Hong Kong has tightened controls on tobacco use. But as soon as lawmakers voted almost unanimously for sweeping new measures, there were calls for them to be toughened. The new measures include bans on possessing or using alternative smoking products in public by next April, and on selling flavoured cigarettes other than menthol varieties by 2027. The exception of menthol keeps the city out of step with bans elsewhere. Supporters say non-menthol flavours, which have grown in popularity among young people, should be tackled first in a strategic step-by-step approach, while banning menthol now could push people towards the black market. Critics say the decision undermines other measures.

The legislation is aimed at further reducing Hong Kong’s smoking rate, now 9.1 per cent of the population. A schools organisation has called for tougher measures, including banning vaping devices. The new measures target substances in alternative smoking products, such as e-liquids or capsules, heat sticks and herbal cigarettes, but not devices used to consume them. “I hope the government will set a timeline to ban vaping devices to protect students,” Langton Cheung Yung-pong, honorary chairman of the Hong Kong Aided Primary School Heads Association, told a radio programme.

Smoking is to be prohibited within three metres of the entrances to schools, childcare centres and hospitals. Some lawmakers also called on the government to prohibit the practice of “smoking while walking”, the bane of the non-smoking majority on the streets.

Advertisement

Most lawmakers were rightly not persuaded by arguments that banning alternative and flavoured tobacco products could harm the economy by discouraging tourism. Most tourists would be more likely to be discouraged if they believed the environment to be heavily polluted by tobacco smoke.

Enforcement of a multipronged tobacco control regime will be a challenge. In that regard, the government should seriously consider lawmakers’ suggestions to offer clear instructions on the city’s smoking rules in multiple languages at tourism hotspots and border control points, and to launch education and awareness efforts in schools ahead of the implementation of the new measures.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x