Advertisement
Hong Kong courts
Opinion
SCMP Editorial

Editorial | Jimmy Lai verdict a testament to Hong Kong’s rule of law

The national security law trial was conducted in Hong Kong’s open courts and showcases their professionalism

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
7
A Correctional Services Department vehicle carrying Jimmy Lai is escorted by police to West Kowloon Magistrates’ Court on December 15. Photo: Sam Tsang
Hong Kong has had its share of internationally high-profile court cases. Few, if any, have attracted the sustained high-level scrutiny at home and abroad of the national security case of Jimmy Lai Chee-ying. The former media boss has been found guilty by three High Court judges of two charges of colluding with foreign forces and a third of conspiracy to print seditious articles. The court found he used his news outlet and social media platforms to trigger international sanctions and incite public disaffection towards authorities between April 2019 and June 2021.

The trial spanned 156 days, with 52 days dedicated to Lai’s testimony. After the guilty verdicts, the founder of the now defunct Apple Daily could face up to life in jail. Sentencing of the 78-year-old, on a date to be fixed, will continue to rivet international attention. Lai can appeal and a date in January has been fixed to plead mitigation.

He was accused of attacking and trying to overthrow the Communist Party’s rule and the Hong Kong government by calling for the United States to impose sanctions when meeting American politicians, and of inciting hatred in his publication.

Advertisement

The West tried to misrepresent the trial as damaging to press freedom and an example of the demise of the rule of law. Beijing and the Hong Kong government have repeatedly stressed Lai’s case has nothing to do with press freedom but is about national security.

Lai is the most prominent figure yet to be prosecuted under the national security law imposed by Beijing in June 2020. But from the time of his arrest, it was more than just about Lai being put on trial, as the city in which he rose and fell had to demonstrate it would uphold the core values in the Basic Law, including an independent judiciary and free speech and the rule of law.

Advertisement

It is therefore time to reflect on the trial and the factors in the process by which Lai was found guilty. In that regard, the process stands up to scrutiny.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x